MLB Player Prop Bets September 11: Four Picks for Thursday

Publish Date: 09/11/2025
Fact checked by: Meghan

It’s a slow Thursday for baseball, but there are still plenty of great bets to be found across the MLB. With nine games happening on the slate, a few players find themselves in favorable betting situations.

This article covers our four favorite player props on the day. It does that by looking at the data and breaking down different statistics to explain the reasoning behind each one.

1. Cal Raleigh to Hit a Home Run vs. Angels (+325)

Our favorite home run bet on the day comes from Seattle. Cal Raleigh is having an incredible season from a power standpoint. He’s hit 53 long balls this season and is always a threat to get a hold of one. While his average isn’t quite at the same level, he goes into a great situation on Thursday.

The power hitter will face Jose Soriano (4.07 ERA). The Angels pitcher started off the year at a relatively good pace, but has a problem when it comes to giving up the long ball. He’s allowed eight home runs across his last nine starts, and that trend doesn’t seem to be slowing down.

During his last time on the mound Soriano allowed eight earned runs against the A’s in just 2.1 innings pitched. That tendency to give up bad pitches, combined with Raleigh’s raw power, makes this a solid long ball bet.

2. Bryan Reynolds to Hit a Home Run vs. Orioles (+576)

While Camden Yards has one of the deepest left field fences in the MLB, we’re going for the big hit with this one. Bryan Reynolds is not a true slugger. He’s only hit fifteen home runs this season and isn’t exactly a perennial threat at the plate. Even so, there’s a lot to like here.

Not only is Reynolds facing Cade Povich (5.16 ERA) but he’s heating up at the right time. Povich struggles with giving up the long ball. Over the last month he’s given up 1.83 home runs per outing with a 42.1 percent FB. That’s great for opposing hitters no matter how you look at it.

In addition, Reynolds hits much better against left-handed pitching. He’s smashing .246/.327/.446 with six home runs when facing south paws this year. He also has a .500 SLG over the last week, showing just how much he’s been heating up. If you’re looking for a sneaky bet with a big pay out, this one is a solid chance to take.

3. Bryce Harper Over 1.5 Bases vs. Mets (+120)

Bryce Harper might not be having the strongest season average-wise (.263) but the slugger is always a threat to get a big hit. He homered in his last game, and continues to see the ball extremely well. He should take that momentum into Thursday’s matchup against New York.

He faces off against David Peterson (3.72 ERA). While the southpaw is having a decent season overall, his ERA has shot up to 6.69 over his last seven starts. He’s been inconsistent, which could lead to him giving up a multi-base hit. Harper also sees him extremely well.

The Phillies slugger is 9-for-24 with a home run against Peterson in his career. He’s batting .270 when facing left handed pitchers this season, and is hitting .299 at home. All of that combines to make it more than likely he gets a few bases.

4. Kevin Gausman Over 17.5 Outs Recorded vs. Astros (-118)

Kevin Gausman might not have the lowest ERA in the league (3.63), but he’s having a strong year all around when it comes to staying in games. The right hander doesn't get the best run support, but he’s a workhorse who can shut down opposing offenses.

Gausman has allowed less than 2.5 runs in back-to-back starts and in four of his last five outings, including a one-run masterpiece against the Yankees. He can get rolling early, and if he does the Blue Jays like to keep him out on the mound.

That tendency to go long is why we like this bet. The Astros aren’t the strongest hitting team this season, and could struggle early. If they do, or if Gausman hits his spots, there’s no reason why he can’t go more than six innings.

All lines courtesy of DraftKings and BetMGM.

Read Also
Want Even More Picks To Profit From?
Money Line -116 FanDuel +100 BetMGM
Spread -1.5 -105 DraftKings 1.0 -110 BetMGM
Over/Under -102 FanDuel DraftKings
Money Line +176 FanDuel -200 BetMGM
Spread 3.5 -102 FanDuel -3.5 -105 BetMGM
Over/Under -108 DraftKings DraftKings
Money Line +130 DraftKings -152 FanDuel
Spread 3.0 -115 BetMGM -3.0 -102 DraftKings
Over/Under -108 DraftKings DraftKings
Money Line +455 DraftKings -592 FanDuel
Spread 10.0 -105 BetMGM -10.5 -104 FanDuel
Over/Under -110 BetMGM DraftKings
Money Line -180 DraftKings +154 BetMGM
Spread -3.5 +100 DraftKings 3.5 -115 BetMGM
Over/Under -110 FanDuel DraftKings
Money Line +135 BetMGM -150 Fanatics
Spread 2.5 -102 FanDuel -3.0 -102 BetMGM
Over/Under -108 FanDuel DraftKings
Money Line -1299 Fanatics +950 DraftKings
Spread -14.5 +100 FanDuel 14.0 -105 Fanatics
Over/Under -105 Fanatics DraftKings
Money Line -375 BetMGM +320 DraftKings
Spread -7.5 -105 BetMGM 7.5 -105 BetMGM
Over/Under -105 DraftKings DraftKings
Money Line -190 BetMGM +164 DraftKings
Spread -3.5 -105 DraftKings 3.5 -110 Fanatics
Over/Under -105 FanDuel DraftKings
Money Line +187.5 FanDuel -218 DraftKings
Spread 4.5 -114 FanDuel -4.5 -105 DraftKings
Over/Under -102 DraftKings DraftKings
Money Line +370 DraftKings -450 Fanatics
Spread 8.5 -105 FanDuel -8.5 -108 DraftKings
Over/Under -108 FanDuel DraftKings
Money Line +300 BetMGM -350 FanDuel
Spread 7.0 -102 FanDuel -7.5 +100 DraftKings
Over/Under -108 DraftKings DraftKings
Money Line +810 FanDuel -1000 BetMGM
Spread 13.5 -106 FanDuel -13.5 -105 DraftKings
Over/Under -105 DraftKings DraftKings
Money Line -115 Fanatics +102 FanDuel
Spread -1.5 -105 DraftKings 1.5 -110 FanDuel
Over/Under -110 FanDuel DraftKings
Money Line -140 BetMGM +120 DraftKings
Spread -2.5 -105 BetMGM 2.5 -105 DraftKings
Over/Under -105 DraftKings DraftKings
Latest News
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: November 5, 2025
  The 2025 NFL trade deadline has officially ...
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: November 4, 2025
📅 What’s Going On in Sports Today The ...
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: November 3, 2025
Week 9 of the NFL season brought chaos, ...
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: October 31, 2025
Lamar Jackson made his long-awaited return Thursday night, ...
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: October 30, 2025
  The Toronto Blue Jays are one win ...
Follow our free plays
Choose your preferred channel:
Wanna make consistent profits with online sports betting?

21+ and present in OH. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

This site is using Cloudflare and adheres to the Google Safe Browsing Program. We adapted Google's Privacy Guidelines to keep your data safe at all times.
CloudflareSSL
Close
Top 3 Sportsbook Bonuses
BetMGM
BetMGM Promo
Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win
Our Favorite
T&Cs and 21+ apply
Code:
Open BetMGM
Get Bonus
DraftKings
DraftKings Promo
New DraftKings Customers: Spend $5+ Get $150 in Bonus Bets *Paid Within 14 Days
Quick Draft
T&Cs and 21+ apply
Code:
Open DraftKings
Get Bonus
FanDuel
FanDuel Promo
New Users – Bet $5 Get $200 in Bet Reset Tokens for 5 Days
Newcomer
T&Cs and 21+ apply
Code:
Open FanDuel
Get Bonus
Wanna make consistent profits with online sports betting?