MLB Player Prop Bets for September 16: Four Bets for Tuesday

Publish Date: 09/16/2025
Fact checked by: Collin

There’s plenty of baseball to be played on what is shaping up to be an action-packed Tuesday. A lot of teams are suiting up across the league, which provides ample opportunities for strong bets.

In this article we cover our favorite prop bets from around the league. That includes home run picks, RBIs, and out recorded. We explain each one, the data behind it, as well as the various reasons we like it over similar bets.

1. Romy Gonzalez to Hit a Home Run vs. Athletics (+501)

There are several strong home candidates around the league today, but our first is Romy Gonzalez. The right hander may not be known for his deep ball ability, but there are several reasons we like this as a riskier bet for a big pay out.

First, the Red Sox face Jeffrey Springs (4.28 ERA). The starter has allowed 1.59 home runs per nine innings this season, and that number has gone up to 1.69 home runs over the past month. He also has a lot of trouble against right handers, allowing 25 of his 28 long balls to that side of the plate. The Green Monster also gives righties a better chance to knock one out.

Gonzalez is a great hitter, but he’s especially strong (.347/.394/.629) against lefties. Adding on the fact that Gonzalez is perhaps the hottest hitter in Boston's lineup, and there are many factors that create a favorable situation for him this afternoon.

2. Matt Olson to Hit a Home Run vs. Nationals (+284)

Where Gonzalez is an under-the-radar pick, Matt Olson has a little more juice behind him. The Braves first basemen has always been a threat to get a ball out of the park, and he’s been absolutely on fire during the last two weeks.

In that span, covering 12 games, he’s hitting .390 with five home runs. He also hit .429 and three home runs in the last week. He takes that momentum into a game against Jake Irvin (5.70), who has given up 33 home runs across 30 starts this season.

Olson has also homered 20 times against right-handed pitchers and tends to see them quite well. That, combined with Irvin’s incredibly inconsistent 9.00 ERA over his last seven starts, could give the first baseman plenty of chances to go deep.

3. Aaron Judge Over 0.5 RBI vs. Twins (+135)

Aaron Judge could very well be the best hitter in baseball. He’s slugging .325 and is always a threat to do damage when he steps into the batter’s box. That’s why we like him to knock in at least one run when facing off against the Twins Zebby Matthews (5.06 ERA).

Matthews is a very inconsistent arm who loves to hang plenty of pitches over the plate. Even if Judge doesn’t get a hold of one, which does seem likely in the incredibly hitter-friendly Target Field, he’ll have plenty of chances to knock someone home with a strong single or double.

Not only that, but Target Field has the fifth-highest altitude in the MLB and the game is set to have mild temperature and humidity. Those all add up to create a pro-hitter atmosphere that Judge could easily take advantage of throughout the game.

4. Cristopher Sanchez Over 17.5 Outs Recorded vs. Dodgers (-165)

Cristopher Sanchez goes into Tuesday up against one of the best teams in the majors. Even so, we like the lefty to make it six innings. That’s because he’s a very strong arm who has only gotten better and more refined throughout the season.

Sanchez posts an incredibly impressive 2.57 ERA, and knows how to shut down opposing offenses. He has a strong pitch set, and while the Dodgers are always a threat to score, he’s only gone under six innings once over his last ten starts.

He’s a workhorse who’s able to stay in games. Philadelphia also isn’t afraid to keep him on the mound. There have been multiple starts where he’s given up four runs and gone past the six inning mark. That makes him our favorite pitcher bet on the day.

All lines courtesy of DraftKings and BetMGM

Read Also
Want Even More Picks To Profit From?
Money Line -140 BetMGM +120 DraftKings
Spread -2.5 -105 BetMGM 2.5 -105 DraftKings
Over/Under -105 DraftKings DraftKings
Money Line +210 DraftKings -240 Fanatics
Spread 5.0 -105 BetMGM -5.0 -105 BetMGM
Over/Under -108 DraftKings DraftKings
Money Line +270 DraftKings -325 BetMGM
Spread 6.5 -102 BetMGM -7.0 -110 FanDuel
Over/Under -110 DraftKings DraftKings
Money Line +108 FanDuel -120 DraftKings
Spread 1.5 -108 FanDuel -1.5 -110 DraftKings
Over/Under -104 FanDuel DraftKings
Money Line +730 FanDuel -1000 BetMGM
Spread 13.5 -102 DraftKings -13.5 -110 FanDuel
Over/Under -108 DraftKings DraftKings
Money Line +205 DraftKings -230 FanDuel
Spread 4.5 -105 BetMGM -5.5 -102 FanDuel
Over/Under -110 FanDuel DraftKings
Money Line +190 FanDuel -225 DraftKings
Spread 4.5 -108 DraftKings -4.5 -105 Fanatics
Over/Under -108 DraftKings DraftKings
Money Line -190 BetMGM +176 FanDuel
Spread -3.5 -110 FanDuel 3.5 -105 Fanatics
Over/Under -105 FanDuel DraftKings
Money Line +300 DraftKings -350 BetMGM
Spread 7.0 -105 BetMGM -7.5 -102 FanDuel
Over/Under -110 BetMGM DraftKings
Money Line -148 DraftKings +132 FanDuel
Spread -3.0 -102 FanDuel 3.0 -115 DraftKings
Over/Under -102 FanDuel DraftKings
Money Line +130 FanDuel -145 BetMGM
Spread 2.5 +100 DraftKings -2.5 -115 FanDuel
Over/Under -110 FanDuel DraftKings
Money Line -175 BetMGM +160 Fanatics
Spread -3.5 -105 DraftKings 3.5 -110 BetMGM
Over/Under -105 Fanatics DraftKings
Money Line -629 Fanatics +490 FanDuel
Spread -12.5 -106 FanDuel 12.5 -110 BetMGM
Over/Under -102 DraftKings DraftKings
Money Line +145 BetMGM -154 FanDuel
Spread 3.0 -110 FanDuel -3.0 -108 DraftKings
Over/Under -110 Fanatics DraftKings
Money Line -426 Fanatics +360 FanDuel
Spread -8.5 -110 FanDuel 8.5 -108 DraftKings
Over/Under -106 FanDuel DraftKings
Latest News
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: November 5, 2025
  The 2025 NFL trade deadline has officially ...
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: November 4, 2025
📅 What’s Going On in Sports Today The ...
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: November 3, 2025
Week 9 of the NFL season brought chaos, ...
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: October 31, 2025
Lamar Jackson made his long-awaited return Thursday night, ...
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: October 30, 2025
  The Toronto Blue Jays are one win ...
Follow our free plays
Choose your preferred channel:
Wanna make consistent profits with online sports betting?

21+ and present in VA. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

This site is using Cloudflare and adheres to the Google Safe Browsing Program. We adapted Google's Privacy Guidelines to keep your data safe at all times.
Virginia Town HallCloudflareSSL
Close
Top 3 Sportsbook Bonuses
BetMGM
BetMGM Promo
Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win
Our Favorite
T&Cs and 21+ apply
Code:
Open BetMGM
Get Bonus
DraftKings
DraftKings Promo
New DraftKings Customers: Spend $5+ Get $150 in Bonus Bets *Paid Within 14 Days
Quick Draft
T&Cs and 21+ apply
Code:
Open DraftKings
Get Bonus
FanDuel
FanDuel Promo
New Users – Bet $5 Get $200 in Bet Reset Tokens for 5 Days
Newcomer
T&Cs and 21+ apply
Code:
Open FanDuel
Get Bonus
Wanna make consistent profits with online sports betting?