MLB Game Bets and Over/Under for September 17: Four Bets for Wednesday

Publish Date: 09/17/2025
Fact checked by: Collin

Baseball action continues as we speed towards the postseason. There are plenty of teams still fighting for their playoff chances, as well as many great betting opportunities down the stretch.

This guide covers our four favorite game picks for today, as well as the over/under bet for each one. We analyze those choices by looking at each decision and then taking a deep dive into the statistics and data behind each one.

1. Cubs (-157) @ Pirates (+132), Over/Under 8

On paper, this game looks like a slam dunk. The Pirates continue to flounder as one of baseball’s worst teams, while the Cubs are about to punch their ticket to the postseason. However, due to the pitchers, it’s closer than it looks at first glance.

The Cubs will start Matthew Boyd (3.05 ERA) against the Pirates Johan Oviedo (2.81 ERA). Both are strong, but come with flaws. Oviedo is largely inexperienced (only six starts) and Boyd’s ERA is 5.31 over his last seven games. Despite that, we like the Cubs.

The Pirates are not a strong team. They’ve only have one win in their last ten games, while Chicago is on a three-game win streak. They have more to play for as well. All of that leads to what should be a solid win for the visiting team.

Eight is not a lot of runs, especially with the Pirates weak bullpen. Even so, Pittsburgh’s sluggish offense and the strong pitching duo lead us to take the under in this one.

2. Giants (-107) @ Diamondbacks (-112), Over/Under 9

In a battle of two favorites, it’s typical to pick the team with the hot hand. In this case, that’s the Diamondbacks. The Giants have had a miserable last two months, and that’s continued as of late. They have won three of their last ten and are on a four-game losing streak.

In contrast, Arizona has won four in a row, plays with a lot more pep, and has stronger bats. They are top ten in team average and rank third in the MLB in RBIs. The Giants are 26th and 17th in those categories, respectively.

That’s a big difference that could help cover the starting pitcher discrepancy. Justin Verlander (3.94 ERA) takes the mound for the Giants against the worse Brandon Pfaadt (5.31 ERA). That could lead the Giants to have a better start, but Arizona’s powerful offense should win the day.

While Verlander has done a good job this season, Arizona’s hitting should put together some runs. The Giants will get some hits against the Diamondbacks’ low-ranked bullpen as well. We like the over.

3. Blue Jays (-130) @ Rays (+109), Over/Under 8

This is another tale of two teams headed in opposite directions. While the Rays have some glimpses of hope here and there, they have absolutely plummeted over the past two weeks. They are on a three game losing streak and have won just two of their last ten.

On the other side, the Blue Jays continue to soar. Not only do they have one of the best records in baseball, they are in the middle of an impressive six-game winning streak and will send Kevin Gausman (3.44 ERA) to the mound.

While the Rays counter with Ian Seymour (2.95 ERA), his pitching alone shouldn’t be enough to close the gap. Both teams are starting great arms, but the Blue Jays hitting and momentum should be enough to take the day.

This is a low line for two offenses that can put the bat on the ball. While both starting pitchers are capable, each team can hit and has middling bullpens. That’s why we like this over.

4. Marlins (-163) @ Rockies (+136), Over/Under 10.5

This is our biggest favorite pick of the day, and for good reason. The Rockies are the worst team in baseball by a wide margin. They have a stagnant offense, bad defense, and an incredibly weak starting rotation that always seems to give up runs.

They’re unlikely to buck that trend on Wednesday, as they plan to start McCade Brown (9.88 ERA) against Marlins ace Ryan Weathers. The lefty only has six starts, but has posted an impressive 2.73 ERA during his time on the mound.

That discrepancy alone should be enough for Miami, especially considering the Rockies are bottom ten in the league for average and RBIs. There’s nothing to like about Colorado, and the Marlins should take care of business.

With the Rockies being as bad as they are, this is a game that should see a lot of runs cross the plate. Normally it’s risky going with lines this high, but we like the over due to the high altitude stadium as well.

All lines courtesy of CBS Sports.

Read Also
MLB Game Bets and Over/Under September 30: Four Bets for Tuesday
The regular season is in the rearview mirror. After a lot of ...
MLB Game Picks and Over/Under for September 24: Four Picks for Wednesday
Every day we get closer to the end. The MLB regular season ...
BetMGM Promo
MLB Game Bets and Over/Under for September 15: Four Bets for Monday
It’s a new week of MLB action. There are nine games around ...
MLB Game Bets and Over/Under for September 12: Four Picks for Friday
Friday is always a big day for the MLB. There are a ...
MLB Game Picks and Over/Under for September 9: Four picks for Wednesday
Baseball continues to speed towards the postseason. There are many teams playing ...
Want Even More Picks To Profit From?
Money Line +150 Fanatics -174 FanDuel
Spread 3.0 -104 FanDuel -3.5 +100 Fanatics
Over/Under -110 BetMGM FanDuel
Money Line -120 FanDuel +105 Fanatics
Spread -1.5 -108 BetMGM 1.5 -110 FanDuel
Over/Under -110 BetMGM FanDuel
Money Line +110 BetMGM -126 FanDuel
Spread 1.5 -110 FanDuel -2.0 -108 BetMGM
Over/Under -105 FanDuel FanDuel
Money Line -155 BetMGM +136 FanDuel
Spread -3.0 -102 BetMGM 2.5 +100 FanDuel
Over/Under -108 BetMGM FanDuel
Money Line +125 BetMGM -146 FanDuel
Spread 2.5 +100 Fanatics -2.5 -118 BetMGM
Over/Under -108 BetMGM FanDuel
Money Line -500 BetMGM +410 FanDuel
Spread -10.5 -105 FanDuel 10.5 -110 BetMGM
Over/Under -102 FanDuel FanDuel
Money Line -285 BetMGM +235 FanDuel
Spread -6.5 -105 FanDuel 6.5 -110 BetMGM
Over/Under -108 BetMGM FanDuel
Money Line -225 BetMGM +194 FanDuel
Spread -4.5 -110 BetMGM 4.5 -104 FanDuel
Over/Under -106 FanDuel FanDuel
Money Line +185 BetMGM -220 FanDuel
Spread 4.5 -110 BetMGM -4.5 -105 Fanatics
Over/Under -105 Fanatics FanDuel
Money Line +166 FanDuel -195 Fanatics
Spread 3.5 -106 FanDuel -3.5 -110 BetMGM
Over/Under -104 FanDuel FanDuel
Money Line -175 BetMGM +155 Fanatics
Spread -3.5 -105 Fanatics 3.0 +100 FanDuel
Over/Under -110 BetMGM FanDuel
Latest News
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: November 5, 2025
  The 2025 NFL trade deadline has officially ...
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: November 4, 2025
📅 What’s Going On in Sports Today The ...
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: November 3, 2025
Week 9 of the NFL season brought chaos, ...
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: October 31, 2025
Lamar Jackson made his long-awaited return Thursday night, ...
PromoGuy Daily +EV Picks: October 30, 2025
  The Toronto Blue Jays are one win ...
Follow our free plays
Choose your preferred channel:
Wanna make consistent profits with online sports betting?

21+ and present in OH. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

This site is using Cloudflare and adheres to the Google Safe Browsing Program. We adapted Google's Privacy Guidelines to keep your data safe at all times.
CloudflareSSL
Close
Top 3 Sportsbook Bonuses
BetMGM
BetMGM Promo
Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win
Our Favorite
T&Cs and 21+ apply
Code:
Open BetMGM
Get Bonus
DraftKings
DraftKings Promo
New DraftKings Customers: Bet $5, Get $200 + 3 Months of NBA League Pass!
Quick Draft
T&Cs and 21+ apply
Code:
Open DraftKings
Get Bonus
FanDuel
FanDuel Promo
New Users – Get $350 in Bonus Bets when you wager $5 for 7 days
Newcomer
T&Cs and 21+ apply
Code:
Open FanDuel
Get Bonus
Wanna make consistent profits with online sports betting?